What's Santa got in his bag for Superman this year? A brand-new Toyman, made in Japan, that's who. And he's looking to add Metallo to his collection of giant robots!

It's Christmas time in Metropolis, and Superman has plenty of fan mail to answer. However, in the middle of the city, there is a battle going on! New Toyman is pummeling Metallo with hundreds of tiny electronic Superman figures, claiming that the parts that built Metallo rightfully belong to him, the Toyman.

Superman dispatches them easily, and returns to the Daily Planet as Clark Kent, where he finds one more piece of mail. It turns out to be one last holiday wish, this one from Lois. She is in Egypt, and she misses him. Then, the story ends with a shocking discovery--Lex Luthor knew that Lois' father was going to die--before it happened!!